Darby’s Dungeon: Where Pints, Puzzles and Polyhedral Shenanigans Collide!

May 31, 2023
3 mins read

Words by Carmen Macri 


When my boyfriend called and asked if I wanted to go to Darby’s Dungeon with him, I was a little concerned. Not knowing anything about the place besides the name, my head went straight into the gutter (can you blame me?). But upon arrival, I was more than pleasantly surprised. No, It wasn’t a BDSM shop; it was better. 

We were met with a welcoming troll, hundreds of board games and a bar — a Dungeons and Dragons-themed bar/coffee shop. (Not a full bar, but it gets the job done.) The tables are lined with fantasy maps with dragon and ogre heads mounted on the wall above. 

Darby Montgomery, the proud owner and namesake of Darby’s Dungeon, was sick and tired of having no place (besides her own “dungeon”) for game nights, so, she decided to take matters into her own hands back in March 2019, boldly proclaiming, “F*** it, I’m making this happen!” And thus, her saga began.

“We would go to restaurants or bars, but they don’t want us sitting there for five hours. And the card shops around here were kind of gross,” Montgomery explained. “I just couldn’t get over the idea that, like, I could do this.”

After the realization, Montgomery wasted no time springing into action. With a burning desire to unleash something truly outlandish upon the unsuspecting Jacksonville scene, she dove in headfirst. Unfortunately, the timing was not on her side. Montgomery was returning from a tradeshow in Nevada, carrying valuable inventory worth more than $5,000, when the entire country unexpectedly went into lockdown. Rather than spending more on contractors and painters, Montgomery gathered her closest companions and made it a DIY dungeon. With the shop serving as an ideal blank canvas, Montgomery and her team had the opportunity to transform her visions into reality. However, due to a limited budget in the initial stages, the outcome had a “raw” aesthetic.

“We painted it this horrible color, I absolutely hated it,” Montgomery explained. “Then we put this B.S. carpet down that came in eight-by-eight squares. We literally just duct taped them down. I just handed one of my friends my credit card and said, ‘Go to Home Depot and find something.’” 

Because of Montgomery’s consistent hosting of game nights at her residence, she managed to amass a considerable fan base. Consequently, when the time came for the grand opening, she already found herself surrounded by a dedicated clientele. There was no worry that Montgomery might struggle to bring in a crowd. Her loyal game partners and friends might have been more excited than she. 

“I had been doing a bunch of events just getting the brand out there and doing a bunch on social media,” Montgomery said. “And so by the time I opened my doors, I had 1,400 followers. People felt like they were a part of this whole thing. Whenever it finally opened, they’re like, ‘Oh, my God, I’ve been waiting for this.’”

Throughout our brief interview, the bar became teeming with a bustling crowd. In fact, it was so packed that Montgomery and I had to find a new spot to chat, surrendering our tabletop to a duo of avid gamers in need. And according to Montgomery, that’s an average night. Especially on the gbweekend or Tuesday night — Ladies Night— when ladies get a dollar off drinks and no table fees while Montgomery and the rest of the dungeon have free rein to “yell at men for being the absolute worst.” (I mean, c’mon. Sign me up.) 

Driven by her personal experience, Montgomery aspires to cultivate an inclusive environment where women feel genuinely embraced within this community. “Ladies Night is great for getting the ladies out and meeting new people that have similar interests,” Montgomery explained. “Going into … games [as a woman], seriously, like, you immediately feel like a pariah. It doesn’t work. If you’re a woman, you’re getting shit on” 

On Wednesday nights, Darby’s Dungeon dedicates their evenings to RPG (Role Play Game) sessions. Montgomery also emphasized that this particular night is exceptionally welcoming to beginners, further fostering the inclusive and accommodating atmosphere (though, Montgomery does recommend reaching out to her personally or through the shop’s social pages to rent a table in advance because the advanced players might gobble up the newbies). Fridays are Board Game Social nights which offer a wonderful opportunity to connect with like-minded individuals who share your passion. It’s an excellent occasion to forge new friendships and expand your social circle.

Darby’s Dungeon extends a warm invitation to anyone and everyone — with the only caveat being a simple request: “Don’t be an asshole.” So, if you’re in near Beach Boulevard and San Pablo Road and seeking a refreshingly different experience away from the ordinary Jacksonville haunts, check out Darby’s Dungeon. But be aware — there are three rules you must follow.

“No Jenga, no magic tricks and NO karaoke,” Montgomery says. “Jenga is jarring when it falls and startles me. Karaoke? No. Why the f*** would I do karaoke?” 

Since a young age, Carmen Macri knew she wanted to be a writer. She started as our student intern and has advanced to Multi-media Journalist/Creative. She graduated from the University of North Florida and quickly found her home with Folio Weekly. She juggles writing, photography and running Folio’s social media accounts.

Current Issue


Submit Events




Current Month

Follow FOLIO!

Previous Story

Once Upon a Time in Jacksonville

Next Story

Folio’s Survival Guide to Music Festival Season

Latest from Business

Simply Stitch Co.

Words by Jillian Lombardo In today’s competitive business landscape, standing out from the crowd is crucial. Simply Stitch Co., a Jacksonville-based business, empowers companies to do just that. They offer exceptional embroidery, screen printing, and eye-catching vehicle wraps, all delivered with a commitment to exceptional customer service and lightning-fast turnaround

We Are Itching to Know More About Fleabag

Words by Carmen Macri  For those of us who’ve witnessed Jacksonville’s evolution, it’s no secret how disheartening the transformation of Jacksonville Beach Pier has been. Our grandparents never tire of reminiscing about the good old days when it was a bustling hub of shops, rides, and carnival games. However, those

Teachers wanted: How politics has infiltrated Florida classrooms

Words by Mallory Pace School is back in session for Florida students, but as the state faces another year with a short staff of teachers, both school and alarm bells are ringing.  Florida’s teacher shortage dates back to 2016 when the Florida Education Association first counted 2,400 open

Lets Be Real

Words by Amiyah Golden  As a blossoming 21-year-old, my post-college fears aren’t limited to career options or how much my first month’s deposit will be — but the overwhelming fear of finding … adult friends.  Scary! I’m curious as to how my mom made friends as an

For the Record …

For the Record … By Ambar Ramirez Before there were music streaming services, mp3 players and CDs, before we were illegally downloading music onto our desktops, there were cassettes and vinyl records. The latter faced a kiss of death within the music industry during the late 1980s and