The Conspirator Movie Review

April 19, 2011
by
2 mins read

by Rick Grant
146 years ago, (1865) the Civil War was over, leaving pervasive grief throughout the land and bitterness in the South. Incredibly, 625,000 men died and many more were horribly maimed.
President Lincoln wanted to move on as a united nation, healing the deep wounds of war. However there were many ex-Confederate soldiers who refused to accept the outcome of the war. They vowed to fight on as a loosely knit band of guerilla fighters.
A cadre of these bitter ex-soldiers were living at Mary Surratt’s boarding house, including her son. They would regularly conduct secret meetings, plotting to kidnap President Lincoln and hold him for ransom to pay back the enormous losses of the Confederacy, now broken and demoralized.
This film, deftly directed by Robert Redford, tells the story of the aftermath of President Lincoln’s assassination by John Wilkes Booth who was tracked down to a barn and killed by a sniper’s bullet. The nation was so outraged by this despicable act of murder, it threatened to destabilize the nation, and reignite the Civil War.
To avert this catastrophe, the Secretary of War (Kevin Kline) decreed that anyone even remotely involved with the conspiracy to assassinate Lincoln was to be rounded up and swiftly tried by a military commission, hanged, and forgotten post haste. Indeed, the brutal murder could have inflamed the passions of the grieving war dead’s relatives to again take up arms.
In the scenario, Redford concentrates on the trial of Mary Surratt, who was represented by a reluctant young lawyer, Frederick Aiken (James McAvoy) appointed to the task. At first, Aiken believes Ms. Surratt is guilty. However, as he talks to her and gets to know her he becomes convinced she knew nothing of the conspiracy.
What ensues is a high tension, superbly acted court-room drama for that time in history. McAvoy is brilliant as defense attorney Aiken. He shocks the court by making constitutionally driven objections to save his client. He gives her a vigorous defense, far beyond what was expected of him.
Of course, Ms. Surratt’s fate was predetermined. The trial was a kangaroo court, with a parade of coached witnesses who blatantly lied. Aiken was livid at such an outrageous miscarriage of justice.
Drawing on his intellectual knowledge of the law, Aiken argued and objected vehemently defending his client. The cigar smoking Commission members create an ominous cloudy background for the intense drama.
As far as court room dramas go, this is one of the best of the genre. Redford’s slow even pacing creates the suspense as Aiken confronts the Commission’s fraudulent agenda.
Because Ms. Surratt’s son was involved with the conspiracy and met with the conspirators in her boarding house, the Commission made an assumption that “how could she not be involved.” In reality, she had no idea what her boarders and son were planning.
The scenario actually has a parallel to today’s world. President Obama promised to close Guantanamo Bay detention center and try the 9/11 conspirators in NYC courts, giving them constitutional rights.
Well, like many other issues during Obama’s first term, he flip-flopped on closing Gitmo and ordered a trial by military tribunal. The decision left Attorney General, Eric Holder, who had lobbied to give the defendants a fair trial by jury in NYC, red faced with embarrassment at being overruled by the White House.

Folio is your guide to entertainment and culture around and near Jacksonville, Florida. We cover events, concerts, restaurants, theatre, sports, art, happenings, and all things about living and visiting Jax. Folio serves more than two million readers across Jacksonville and Northeast Florida, including St. Augustine, The Beaches, and Fernandina.

Current Issue

SUBMIT EVENTS

Submit Events

Advertisements

Welcome to Rockville 2025
SingOutLoadFestival_TheAmp_2025
omaha-steaks-banners

Date

Title

Current Month

Follow FOLIO!

Previous Story

Soul Surfer Movie Review

Next Story

THE GREAT AMERICAN TRAILER PARK MUSICAL theatre review

Latest from Movies

April Theater, Dance and Film

April 1-6 “Les Miserables” Jacksonville Center for the Performing Arts fscjartistseries.org April 3 “A Year With Frog and Toad” Thrasher-Horne Center thcenter.org April 3-11 “Beautiful: The Carole King Story” Alhambra Theatre & Dining alhambrajax.com April 3-13 “Oklahoma!” Artist Connection Theatre artistconnectiontheatre.org April 4 “The Great Gatsby:

Cartoons Are For Kids

Animation is cool Words by Waverly Loyd I asked someone their favorite animated movie, and they said, “I’m an adult. I don’t watch kid’s movies.” And I thought, “Wow, you must be so fun to be around.” (derogatory) Apart from the fact that watching animated movies is good for

Good Girls Go to Heaven, Groupies Go Backstage

The Rise and Fall of Groupies Words by Ambar Ramirez The show begins like any other. Overhead lights dim, stage lights flare and the crowd roars. Backstage, a woman adjusts her smudged eyeliner and pulls her fur-lined coat tight as she watches the band take the stage. She’s not

March Theater, Dance and Film

Through March 2 “The Trojan Women” Flagler College–Lewis Auditorium flagler.edu Through March 9 “Mean Girls” (teen version) Amelia Musical Playhouse ameliamusicalplayhouse.com “Funny Girl” Players by the Sea playersbythesea.org Through March 16 “The Drowsy Chaperone” Limelight Theatre, St. Augustine limelight-theatre.org Through March 30 “West Side Story” Alhambra

This Year’s Best Pictures Ranked Best To Worst

Words by Waverly Loyd Ladies, gents, and theydies alike. The cinephile superbowl is here. The 97th Academy Awards is inching closer with a whopping 48 films receiving nominations. With some controversial takes that have most netizens scratching their heads (*blows a kiss at Emilia Pérez*) and some truly
July 5th Cleanup
GoUp

Don't Miss

The Avett Brothers

November 15 The Avett Brothers St. Augustine Amphitheatre (904) 471-1965

Paula Poundstone

Paula Poundstone “Twitter is the postcards in my head.” It’s