HARRY BROWN movie review

June 8, 2010
by
2 mins read

photo: David Pearce
photo: David Pearce
photo: David Pearce

by Erin Thursby
Harry Brown is a modern Western set in an English city. It’s a vengeance flick, truly, but like those Westerns of yore, all the brutality from the hero just feels right. Harry Brown, excellently played by Michael Caine, loses his best friend to violent criminals. Brown is 70-something pensioner, living in a neighborhood so horrific that, after viewing the film, Satan is remodeling Hell to include graffitied tunnels and Brit thugs in hoodies.
The character of Harry Brown is established in ordinary moments: his butter knife scraping against toast, his daily walk to play chess with a friend, a pull on his inhaler and visiting his wife in the hospital.
But soon the ordinary is shattered. His wife succumbs to her illness and his only friend dies soon afterward. It’s his friend’s brutal murder and Brown’s utter isolation that drives him to seek vengeance. After all, the feckless police can’t seem to anything effective without causing a full-scale riot.
The only morally ambiguous ground belongs to the police in this tale. They’re bound by the law, unable to do what they need to. We find a sympathetic figure in Detective Alice Frampton (Emily Mortimer), who comes to inform Harry of his friend’s violent death. She’s not jaded the way the rest of the department is and she seems to genuinely care about Harry’s loss.
Harry finds his first weapon in a box of memories. Pictures of his now-dead daughter, ticket stubs, photographs and finally, on the bottom— a knife from his military days. It’s apt, because love for his wife and his life had covered over his violent past. He turned his back on all that once he found her.
At this point Harry Brown changes from merely being interesting to watch into a total badass who’s interesting to watch. Sure he has emphysema and you can out run him, but he will totally put a cap in your punk-ass– if you deserve it.
It’s clear who the good guys are and who the bad guys are. There’s no equivocation (except momentarily, for the sake of the ending twist). Because of that, the movie is a bit cathartic. But it’s also a bit simplistic. The gangsters are hideous caricatures of drug-addled chaotic evil. There’s never any questions about how the neighborhood got so terrible– that’s just the way it is. The good people afraid of the bad people, with no power to do anything about it. I know that these questions don’t come to the fore because the writers must drive home: Harry good. Thugs evil.
It’s easy to kill them because the movie establishes that they are less than human as a group. It’s not necessarily a bad thing as far as the movie goes, because the clear delineation between the good guys and the bad guys is what makes it fun. It’s not as unbelievable as it seems. There are kids who tape beatings on their iPhones, who are utterly soulless and conscience-free. But if you’ve never lived or worked or gone to school in a ‘hood like that, if you’ve never been picked completely at random for a beating as you crossed a street, you probably will find it hard to swallow. But yes, these people do exist. And no, they don’t need a real reason other than their own entertainment.
I found myself wondering how differently this movie would play in England. Guns figure strongly into the movie, and the American perception of gun violence is different from the Brit point of view. The director Daniel Barber, though he works in L.A., is a citizen of the UK, and that’s where the movie is set.
All in all, Harry Brown is a departure from the usual vengeance flick because the hero is unconventional, but it still sticks to the black-and-white world view that most films like this must have in order to be satisfying.

Folio is your guide to entertainment and culture around and near Jacksonville, Florida. We cover events, concerts, restaurants, theatre, sports, art, happenings, and all things about living and visiting Jax. Folio serves more than two million readers across Jacksonville and Northeast Florida, including St. Augustine, The Beaches, and Fernandina.

Current Issue

SUBMIT EVENTS

Submit Events

Advertisements

Welcome to Rockville 2025
SingOutLoadFestival_TheAmp_2025
omaha-steaks-banners

Date

Title

Current Month

Follow FOLIO!

Previous Story

SPLICE movie review

Next Story

Savannah drips Southern Charm

Latest from Movies

April Theater, Dance and Film

April 1-6 “Les Miserables” Jacksonville Center for the Performing Arts fscjartistseries.org April 3 “A Year With Frog and Toad” Thrasher-Horne Center thcenter.org April 3-11 “Beautiful: The Carole King Story” Alhambra Theatre & Dining alhambrajax.com April 3-13 “Oklahoma!” Artist Connection Theatre artistconnectiontheatre.org April 4 “The Great Gatsby:

Cartoons Are For Kids

Animation is cool Words by Waverly Loyd I asked someone their favorite animated movie, and they said, “I’m an adult. I don’t watch kid’s movies.” And I thought, “Wow, you must be so fun to be around.” (derogatory) Apart from the fact that watching animated movies is good for

Good Girls Go to Heaven, Groupies Go Backstage

The Rise and Fall of Groupies Words by Ambar Ramirez The show begins like any other. Overhead lights dim, stage lights flare and the crowd roars. Backstage, a woman adjusts her smudged eyeliner and pulls her fur-lined coat tight as she watches the band take the stage. She’s not

March Theater, Dance and Film

Through March 2 “The Trojan Women” Flagler College–Lewis Auditorium flagler.edu Through March 9 “Mean Girls” (teen version) Amelia Musical Playhouse ameliamusicalplayhouse.com “Funny Girl” Players by the Sea playersbythesea.org Through March 16 “The Drowsy Chaperone” Limelight Theatre, St. Augustine limelight-theatre.org Through March 30 “West Side Story” Alhambra

This Year’s Best Pictures Ranked Best To Worst

Words by Waverly Loyd Ladies, gents, and theydies alike. The cinephile superbowl is here. The 97th Academy Awards is inching closer with a whopping 48 films receiving nominations. With some controversial takes that have most netizens scratching their heads (*blows a kiss at Emilia Pérez*) and some truly
July 5th Cleanup
GoUp

Don't Miss

The Avett Brothers

November 15 The Avett Brothers St. Augustine Amphitheatre (904) 471-1965

Paula Poundstone

Paula Poundstone “Twitter is the postcards in my head.” It’s