THE KNIFE

YOUR BAND NAME (PROBABLY) SUCKS

In my 25-plus years as a working journalist, the only article I ever wrote that elicited a call directly to my home phone was one like this

Posted

The last time I wrote an article like this, I received threats of violence on my home voice mail. You may be wondering, “What, pray tell, was that article about? Was it your ‘Godless in the Bible Belt’ cover story? Or possibly the one about Jacksonville’s underground bondage community? Or the thing you wrote about the child molester?”

Nope. In my 25-plus years as a working journalist, the only article I ever wrote that elicited a call directly to my home phone comprised a list of the worst local band names. That’s right, a fan of Hot Cotton, which I picked as the worst local band name at the time (about a decade ago, though memory fails on the precise date), felt so compelled to defend his favorite band’s honor that he found my home phone number and left a profanity-laced Southern-drawl tirade on my voice mail.

It’s been a while since I’ve been threatened for putting words to page, so I thought I’d give it another go-’round. Truth is, most band names suck, and picking the worst is akin to shooting fish in a barrel — lots of dead fish in a very shallow barrel.

There are categories into which most band names fall, some specific to a decade or genre while others are universal through time. For instance, in the ’90s, the worst band names had female names in them: Alice in Chains, Naomi’s Hair, Jennifer’s Car, Jane’s Addiction and Marcy Playground are but a few cringe-worthy examples. There was a time when “wolf” names were considered cool, but most of them sucked, too: Wolf Parade, Wolfmother, Wolf Eyes, Wolves in the Throne Room. Metal and doom bands are notorious for horrible names: Prostitute Disfigurement, Job for a Cowboy, Goblin Cock, Behold … The Arctopus (ellipses included).

And then there is the Holy Crap This Band Has the Longest, Stupidest Name Ever variety. In this category fall … And You Will Know Us By The Trail of Dead (again, ellipses included), The Presidents of the United States of America, and The World is a Beautiful Place and I am No Longer Afraid to Die. And possibly the dumbest band name in history: !!!, which I’m told is pronounced “chk chk chk,” which somehow makes it even stupider.

So this brings us to today in Northeast Florida, and the five worst band names I’ve seen around town. Keep in mind, this isn’t a comment on their music. I haven’t even heard some of these bands. This is an aesthetic judgment only, one that may lead to me getting my ass kicked over the phone. So, without further ado … here it goes. (Had to throw in some ellipses of my own.)

• The Plan B Band: Why, oh why, would you name your act The Plan B Band? The first (and only) thing that comes to my mind is the morning-after pill, and I think I speak for the majority here. A Top 40 cover band, Plan B dresses to the nines, plays a wide variety of likeable music and specializes in weddings. No word on whether they provide the bride with emergency contraception.

• Askmeificare: Maybe I have a general disdain for intentional misspellings and combining several words into one, but this irks me. And I confess, I like this band’s tune “Ex-Boyfriend.” It reminds me of Orange 9mm’s heavier stuff. But the name, if it’s supposed to imply rebellion, suggests mere laziness. Askmeificare. Eh, not really.

• Stump Water: Yes, there is a band called Stump Water. A quick Google search reveals that stump water is a backwoods remedy used to cure warts. Yum!

• Ultra Suck Mega Fuxxx: Not sure what they’re shooting for here. If they’re going for offensive, they missed the mark entirely. Instead, those three Xs reek of desperation. If there’s a joke in there, inside or otherwise,

I don’t get it. It was funny when Primus did it back in the ’90s. Sort of. But if they’re hoping to give off a low-budget gonzo porn film distributor vibe, well, BINGO!

• Stayne Thee Angel: There are so many things wrong with this name, I don’t know where to begin. The intentional misspellings might suggest there’s a double meaning, were a comma employed following “Thee.” Still, being stained by an angel seems less threatening than simply unpleasant. This band’s drummer wears a gas mask, which certainly adds an air of menace to the proceedings. But in the end, what we have is yet another unsuccessful attempt to twist an innocuous phrase into something deep, dark and meaningful.

By the way, there are a handful of local band names that I really appreciate. Ginormous J and Squeedlepuss come to mind. But the A-number-1, top-of-the-list, greatest band name ever?

Jacksonville’s own … Glitterpiss.

6 comments on this story | Add your comment
Please log in or register to add your comment
AskmeIfIcarican1

Watch your effing mouth!!! I know these guys personally and they're anything but lazy. I've been along for the ride since the beginning. You think you can come up with a better name for their band then by all means go the eff ahead until then you can shut your effing pie hole and keep your judgments to yourself. This is what happens when uniformed douchebags with online degrees try to act like they know something pretty soon they're leading the rest of the lemmings off of a cliff. I dont have to call you to tell you that you're dead wrong. The name implies that they don't give a %^@*& about the opinions of people like you. "OH! You don't like our band's name?" #ASKMEIFICARE Wednesday, June 25|Report this

stringenstein

I am in one of the bands on this list and I laughed my ass off when I read this. You won't get any threatening calls from me. Wednesday, June 25|Report this

STAARMY

Well you know what I think Stayne thee angel is one sick ass band an I dont give a hell what anyone says brian darren justin are the best damn musicians I have herd ina while an they rock so anyone has something to say besides what this guy made on this page cause idgaf what is said S.T.A ARMY ALL THE WAY MFS Thursday, June 26|Report this

STA_Vocals

Easy people! I think this is a fun article. It is well written, and it is quite witty. I think it is an honor anytime someone talks about a local band in the press, especially someone with the reputation of John E. Citrone. It means the band is, at a minimum, on the map (so to speak). Each one of us knows what our band name signifies, so it is not needed, nor is it required, to explain them (unless you so wish). I think this article is all in the name of fun. So let me be the first to say, "Thank you". I truly did get a laugh out of this. Much love to all, and remember, SMILE, because it looks great on you. :) Thursday, June 26|Report this

Jennie750608

In all the years you've spent as a journalist, you failed to realize that "stupider" is not proper grammar! It's "more stupid." Thursday, June 26|Report this

DavidNielsen

Funny, I was going to comment on this story & came online, THEN I saw the column's general title, "The Knife"! Interesting. You'll see the connection at the end.

Like most people, I agree it seems most of the GOOD band names have been taken (or just need someone with greater creativity to come up with).

But, around 5 years ago, I was listening to The Greaseman on the radio. (I know, boo, hiss.) He happened to have a lot of good ideas along this line — he was responding to a caller who wondered what name to call his new band, & Grease responded with a dozen or so.

I forget any of the names he came up with albeit one (and there were THREE in particular I'd mentioned to a co-worker right afterwards, but I can't recall the other 2).

But here's that one band name: O..J.'s Knife.

The bit was a real hoot, and I was laughing uncontrollably. And it showed that, with a healthy dose of creative thinking, it's not so hard to come up with a great band name.

(By the way, I was sure the above band-name would be taken up by someone locally by now.) Sunday, June 29|Report this

 
Download our dojax app
What do you think? Browse
Who is the scariest person in Northeast Florida?
Post your review here …