Jacksonville Has an Identity Crisis

On trying to figure out who we are


There is a profound disadvantage as a newcomer to writing a weekly column about a place you know little about. These columns are, by their very design, meant to be authoritative. Yet I still find myself very much a stranger in a strange land, and am wary of inveighing on anything with too much vigor lest I open my mouth only to forcefully insert my foot — to borrow a maxim, "Silence is wisdom when speaking is folly."

So instead of beating my chest and telling you what to think — this page will soon enough have plenty of that as I become more acculturated — I thought it better to pose a question: Who are we? More importantly, what's getting in the way of us figuring 
that out?

This is fundamentally a question of identity, and an important one that, sooner rather than later, we need to answer. And I'm not the only one asking. Last weekend, I had a friend in from out of town, and he noticed the same thing: that Jacksonville, and Northeast Florida generally, seems to lack a sense of place. A few days before that, on my drive into work, I caught a conversation between WJCT's Melissa Ross and Ray Oldakowski, a Jacksonville University geography professor, on just 
this subject.

"A sense of place is just like a personality," Oldakowski told her. "You can have a very nice person who doesn't have a distinct personality trait."

That's a beautifully apt metaphor. Jacksonville is — and Jacksonvillians are — very nice, very pleasant, very easy-going. (Except on the highway; there you're a bunch of assholes.) But is it distinctive — or, rather, is there a singularly defining feature? If so, I've yet to see it.

Oldakowski is focused on creating a national identity, a mental association that the outside world makes when people think of Jacksonville, in the way Memphis has the blues, New Orleans has Bourbon Street, Orlando has Disney, Seattle has the Space Needle and so on. (Jacksonville has … um, a shitty football team and a bunch of insurance companies. Yay.) And so he argues for something iconic, maybe something like that 1,000-foot-tall observation tower being planned for the Shipyards.

That's not without merit. But it seems to me it's asking the wrong question. Finding a sense of place isn't about a new shiny object or clever marketing slogan. It's not about what outsiders think — although if you're interested in attracting cutting-edge employers, finally passing that human rights ordinance would be a good start. (Nobody wants to live in a town run by Baptists.) It's not about constructing the facade of a "world-class" city; it's about actually becoming one.

It's about nurturing a culture. It's about livability. It's about pedestrian and bike and mass transit — and placing less emphasis on cars and beltways — about turning development inward instead of the exurban wilderness. (Sprawl is the avowed enemy of place.) It's about building a robust Downtown not just during bankers' hours. It's about fostering an atmosphere in which it's unacceptable that less than a quarter of adults have bachelor's degrees. It's about prizing the eccentric and innovative over the milquetoast and safe. It's about taking the germs of greatness that exist — e.g., CoRK Arts District, Riverside Arts Market — and encouraging them to blossom.

This sort of movement is happening all over the country. And it can — and should — happen in Jacksonville. The greatest impediment is a lack of imagination, a sense of complacency, a regression toward the status quo.

This — to cite just one example — is why the Riverside Avondale Preservation people are so worked up over the Florida Department of Transportation's proposed widening of the Fuller Warren Bridge, which they fear will suffocate one of Jacksonville's burgeoning neighborhoods under years of construction, not to draw people into the urban core but to help commuters bypass it. Maybe they're overreacting, given the paucity of available details. Then again, maybe overreaction isn't a bad thing. Public comment on the expansion begins next month. We'll have more to say about it then.

In the meantime, my question is this: Who are we? And more important, what do we want to be?

1 comment on this story | Add your comment
Please log in or register to add your comment

Wow Jeffrey, I'm a newcomer too which is why I can relate so well to what you've written. However, I've lived here long enough to know that it's not what you've said but how you've said it that will raise eyebrows and ruffle feathers. It's been my observation that Jacksonville is the "City of Fences" and I could write an entire story from that perspective. It is a city that draws people away not "to" the urban center. This probably explains why such an expansion between the fences and church steeples. If you really want to get a history of where you live, look for a documentary on the HISTORY OF JACKSONVILLE'S BRIDGES.

The "movement" happening all over that is not happening here is an interesting point however you can't fix what no one feels is broken. I've lived in six states, north, midwest and south prior to relocating here one year ago. Folks her are just doing their own thing and every now and then they accidentally bump into each other with their cars. I agree that the driving etiquette is the worst I've seen. I've never lived anywhere where the respect for ones fellow man was so minimized. I'm shocked to see the old and young still smoking cigarettes everywhere. Most of all I've never seen so many fearful white middle aged males gathered in one state. I believe that Jacksonville has a rich history and tradition like any other city, but that has been overshadowed by an influx of people from the rest of Florida, Georgia and the upper 48 who brought too much baggage. A city of fences indeed. Saturday, January 11, 2014|Report this